Wave of boxship fires highlights largescale problem with DG
TT Club says these recent incidents are ‘merely the tip of a failing safety iceberg’, calling on the container supply chain to do more to tackle the incorrect processing of dangerous goods
The recent spate of container ship fires has understandably focused attention on container safety issues, with international transport and logistics insurer and safety campaigner TT Club highlighting the scale of the problem and how “wrongly classified, labelled, packed or simply inaccurately identified dangerous commodities bring the greatest potential risk of disaster”.
The organisation said the recent reports of multiple containership fires “have once more focused those in the container supply chain on safety issues related to the incorrect processing of dangerous goods”, giving renewed impetus to the nascent ‘Cargo Integrity’ campaign initiated by TT Club.
It highlighted the recent fire aboard the ‘Yantian Express’, details of the final judgment on the ‘MSC Flaminia’ explosion in July 2012, and the ongoing investigation of the ‘Maersk Honan’ fire, followed just days ago by the news of the ‘Grande America’ sustaining a container fire in the Bay of Biscay and subsequently sinking.
“These perilous incidents not only frequently cost lives, millions of dollars in cargo losses and ship damage, but also significant delays in cargo supply chains amounting to major disruption across numerous industries in these ‘just-in-time’ days,” TT Club said. “Yet these incidents are merely the tip of a failing safety iceberg. Taking the maritime segment of global supply chain, it is estimated that a major container ship fire at sea occurs on average every 60 days.
“Furthermore, TT Club’s records indicate that across the intermodal spectrum as a whole, 66% of incidents related to cargo damage can be attributed to poor practice in the overall packing process; that is not just in securing but also in cargo identification, declaration, documentation and effective data transfer.” It noted that the calculated cost of these claims in the marine aviation and transport (MAT) insurance sector is in excess of US$500 million a year.
Peregrine Storrs-Fox, TT Club’s risk management director and the man leading the Cargo Integrity campaign, commented: “We are endeavouring to focus all direct and indirect stakeholders on recognising and doing the right thing. One particularly critical aspect of this is the correct declaration and handling of dangerous goods (DG).”
He noted that all types of cargo can be mishandled; but wrongly classified, labelled, packed or simply inaccurately identified dangerous commodities bring the greatest potential risk of disaster.
Estimating the degree of failure to comply with best practices in this regard is not straightforward, he noted. ICHCA International, the cargo handling operatives’ association, has calculated that of the 60 million packed containers moved each year, 10% or 6 million are declared as DG.
“Information from published government inspections, which are invariably biased towards declared DG loads, suggests that 20% of these are poorly packed or incorrectly identified,” TT Club said. “This translates into 1.3 million potentially unstable DG containers traveling around the world each year.”
Storrs-Fox emphasised that this scale of risk is elevated when undeclared or misdeclared DG consignments are considered. “In these cases, an estimate of volumes is more obscure,” he noted.
“An indication has been given through the work of one container carrier, Hapag-Lloyd, developing a profiling algorithm to search its booking system for potential misdeclaration of commodities. Results from Cargo Patrol, when extrapolated to the carryings of all the lines, concludes a reasonable estimate in excess of 150,000 volatile containers in the supply chain each year.”
TT Club said container lines, in particular, are making efforts to mitigate the problem, noting: “The Cargo Incident Notification System (CINS), in which many of the top lines participate, has been active for a number of years and has successfully identified a number of commodities that commonly cause problems during transport – not always limited to those formally identified as dangerous. TT Club has additionally promoted, together with UK P&I Club and Exis Technologies, the Hazcheck Restrictions Portal, which is designed to identify and streamline the complexity of regulations and protocols imposed by carriers and ports around the world in relation to transporting declared dangerous goods.”
However, Storrs-Fox concluded: “There is very much still to be done in achieving true Cargo Integrity. Our diverse campaign is seeking significant cultural and behavioural change to say the least.
“Certain elements may require legislative action, enforcement and inspection and there are great challenges in the field of technological development. Above all, there is a need for all involved in the supply chain to have a realistic perception of risk and a responsible attitude towards liability.”
TT Club is a leading provider of insurance and related risk management services to the international transport and logistics industry. Established in 1968, the Club's membership comprises ship operators, ports and terminals, road, rail and airfreight operators, logistics companies and container lessors.